Because we are often engrossed it our mindstates, it is often very difficult for us to see them

It is one of the great paradoxes of human consciousness: the mind is the tool we use to see everything else, yet it is the one thing we struggle to see clearly.

When you are angry, you don't see "anger"; you see a world full of frustrating people. When you are anxious, you don't see "anxiety"; you see a world full of potential threats. We become so fused with our internal weather that we forget we are the sky.

The Fish and the Water

There is a famous analogy of two young fish swimming along who happen to meet an older fish. The older fish nods at them and says, "Morning, boys. How's the water?" The two young fish swim on for a bit, and then eventually one of them looks over at the other and goes, "What the hell is water?"

Our mindstates—agitation, dullness, craving, or peace—are the "water" we swim in. Because they color every perception we have, they become invisible to us. We don't realize we are wearing blue-tinted glasses; we simply think the world is blue.

Why It Is Difficult to See

The difficulty in seeing our mindstates stems from several psychological and biological factors:

  • Identification: We naturally use the word "I." We say "I am sad" rather than "Sadness is currently passing through the mind." This linguistic habit reinforces the idea that the emotion is our identity.
  • The Survival Loop: Evolutionarily, it was more important to react to a threat (the content of the thought) than to analyze the nature of the fear (the process of the thought).
  • Cognitive Fusion: This is a state where thoughts and reality are inseparable. In this state, a thought is not just a mental event; it is an absolute truth.

Meditation: Stepping Onto the Riverbank

If being lost in a mindstate is like being swept away by a fast-moving river, meditation is the act of climbing out and sitting on the bank.

Meditation doesn't necessarily stop the river from flowing, but it changes your relationship to it. It provides the "psychological gap" necessary to observe the current without being drowned by it.

1. Developing the "Observer"

The core of mindfulness meditation is the cultivation of the Observing Self. You begin to notice the mechanics of your own suffering. You might think, "Ah, there is that tightness in my chest again. My mind is spinning a story about the future. This is what anxiety feels like." This shift from "I am" to "I am noticing" is the beginning of freedom.

2. Labeling the State

A powerful technique in meditation is "noting" or "labeling." By silently naming a state—thinking, feeling, wanting, resisting—you create an objective distance. Scientific studies suggest that the act of labeling an emotion can actually reduce the activity in the amygdala (the brain's fear center).

3. Breaking the Chain of Reactivity

Usually, a mindstate triggers an action. Anger triggers a sharp word; boredom triggers a reach for the phone. Meditation teaches you to feel the urge to act without actually following through. You see the mindstate as a temporary phenomenon—a wave that peaks and then inevitably breaks.

The Goal: Meta-Awareness

Ultimately, the practice leads to Meta-awareness: the ability to be aware of the fact that you are aware.

Instead of being lost in a movie, you suddenly remember you are sitting in a theater watching light hit a screen. The movie might still be a drama or a thriller, but you are no longer in danger. You have found the "water," and in doing so, you have found a way to navigate it with much more grace.